2 Samuel 2 · a question people ask
Could Abner have avoided killing Asahel?
Here is what the chapter says. "Asahel pursued Abner. He didn’t turn to the right hand or to the left from following Abner" (2:19). Abner spoke to him twice. First: "Turn away to your right hand or to your left, and grab one of the young men, and take his armor" (2:21). "But Asahel would not turn away from following him" (2:21). Then: "Turn away from following me. Why should I strike you to the ground? How then could I look Joab your brother in the face?" (2:22). "However, he refused to turn away" (2:23), and Abner struck him, and he died there (2:23). The chapter passes no judgment on Abner or on Asahel. Later chapters come back to it. Joab kills Abner "for the blood of Asahel his brother" (3:27), and the book says, "So Joab and Abishai his brother killed Abner, because he had killed their brother Asahel at Gibeon in the battle" (3:30). David says, "I and my kingdom are guiltless before the LORD forever of the blood of Abner the son of Ner" (3:28), and near the end of his life he says that Joab killed Abner and Amasa "and shed the blood of war in peace" (1 Kings 2:5). None of these verses says whether Abner could have done otherwise, and this answer doesn't go past them.
The verses
“When Abner had returned to Hebron, Joab took him aside into the middle of the gate to speak with him quietly, and struck him there in the body, so that he died for the blood of Asahel his brother. Afterward, when David heard it, he said, “I and my kingdom are guiltless before the LORD forever of the blood of Abner the son of Ner.”
“So Joab and Abishai his brother killed Abner, because he had killed their brother Asahel at Gibeon in the battle.”
““Moreover you know also what Joab the son of Zeruiah did to me, even what he did to the two captains of the armies of Israel, to Abner the son of Ner and to Amasa the son of Jether, whom he killed, and shed the blood of war in peace, and put the blood of war on his sash that was around his waist and in his sandals that were on his feet.”